Lets be honest, age isn’t the best barometer to determine if a person should be trusted with alcohol. I know 10 year olds who would be more responsible with drinking than a lot of 40 year olds. So why in the US is 21 the magic number where we decide people can drink? We do a lot of stuff by age here, so I guess we are just used to it.
A better way, would be to allow people access to alcohol until they prove they can’t handle it. If they can’t handle it, they don’t get it anymore, no matter what age. Obviously there would be a starting age, and I think it should be younger than 21. How many people can honestly raise their hand to say “I had my first drink of alcohol on or after my 21st birthday?” Put your hands down highschoolers, you are lying because your parents are in the room.
Here is how it works, when you go in to a store/bar/etc. to purchase alcohol, they swipe your driver’s license. It tells them if you are allowed to buy alcohol. If you have a DUI/DWI you can’t. Maybe not forever, but at least for a time, you can’t. If you ever committed a felony, like raped a child, you can’t, because you should be in jail and I hate you. If you are under a certain age, lets say 18, you can’t.
But what about XYZ way of getting around it? You can get around being under 21 and drinking in all the same ways, so it isn’t perfect, but it is better than our current system. Instead of waiting until a drunk driver has gotten 5 DWIs, installed a breathalyzer in his car, endangered countless people, etc., he just isn’t allowed to buy alcohol for 1 year after his first DWI. Instead of looking at some 16 year old with an expired driver’s license from their older brother, you swipe it and it shows you that it’s expired and they can’t buy alcohol.
In order to be allowed by TABC to serve alcohol, you have to install a machine that swipes DLs and connects to a network with this information. If you get caught serving people who fail the check, or not checking at all, you get a fine, just like before with underaged drinkers. Yes this means law enforcement has to be a little more cooperative in sharing data from local to national level, but that needs to happen anyway.
Like I said, it isn’t perfect, but I think it is better than the current system.